The first time, it was Dale from the benefits office. I was fresh out of grad school, three weeks into a job that paid $52,000, holding a stack of enrollment forms. “Max out the 401(k),” he said, tapping the page. “Everybody does.”
The second time, it was my uncle at a cookout, pointing a rib at me. Same sentence. Same certainty.
The third time, it was a friend with a spreadsheet and a lot of exclamation points.
I nodded all three times. Then in March, my transmission died forty miles from the trailhead. The repair quote was $2,300. My checking account held $410.
I put it on a credit card that charged 22 percent. Somewhere in that gravel parking lot, the advice stopped sounding like advice.
The advice isn’t wrong. It’s just out of order.
A 401(k) is a retirement account through your job. Money comes out of your paycheck before you ever see it, goes into investments, and grows with a tax break until you’re older. It’s a good tool. I still use mine.
“Maxing out” means putting in the most the government allows. This year, that’s $24,500. On my salary, that would have been 47 percent of every paycheck, before rent, before groceries, before a transmission.
Nobody saying “max out” was lying. They were talking to someone with a cushion. I didn’t have one, and the advice never asked.
What the spreadsheet left out
My friend’s spreadsheet was beautiful. It showed a 401(k) growing at 7 percent a year for forty years, and the final number had a comma in a very exciting place. That’s compound growth: your money earns money, and then that money earns money too. The math is real. I checked it.
What the spreadsheet didn’t have was a row for March. No row for a dead transmission, a dental bill, or a layoff. Life doesn’t show up in a projection until it shows up in your checking account.
And when your cash is all locked inside a retirement account, a surprise leaves you two bad choices. You can borrow at a high rate, or you can pull the money out early and generally pay a penalty on top of the taxes. I didn’t want either.
I’m not saying the spreadsheet was wrong. I’m saying it was missing a row, and the row was me.
The one dollar I never skipped
Here’s the part Dale got completely right. My employer matched what I put in, dollar for dollar, up to 4 percent of my pay. A “match” is free money: you put in a dollar, and the company adds a dollar.
Four percent of $52,000 is $2,080. Matched, that’s $4,160 a year heading into my future, and I only paid half of it. Almost nothing else you can do with money pays that well on day one.
One catch worth knowing: some companies make you stay a year or two before the match is fully yours. That’s called vesting. Read your plan’s fine print.
So I took Dale’s advice. I just took 4 percent of it.
The match is the only part of “max out” that’s free. Everything past it is a choice.
The 22 percent problem
APR stands for annual percentage rate, which is the yearly price of borrowing money. Mine was 22 percent. On $2,300, that’s about $506 a year, just for the privilege of owing it.
The stock market has averaged roughly 10 percent a year over the long haul, with some ugly years mixed in. So paying off that card was a guaranteed 22 percent return. Investing the same dollars and hoping for 10 would have been a bad trade.
I sent $220 a month at the card. It took about a year. Each month the balance dropped, the interest dropped with it, and the payments started to feel like momentum instead of punishment.
The card didn’t care that I was young, or that retirement was a few decades off. It charged interest every month, whether or not I was ready to think about it.
The boring money that came next
When the card hit zero, I pointed the same $220 at a cushion. An emergency fund is cash set aside for surprises. My bills ran about $2,000 a month, so I aimed for three months of them, $6,000, in a separate savings account I wouldn’t be tempted to touch. Boring is the point. A cushion doesn’t earn much, but it buys you the right to stay calm when something breaks.
Then I opened a Roth IRA. An IRA is an individual retirement account, one you open yourself instead of through your boss. With a Roth, you pay the tax now, and the money grows and comes out tax-free in retirement. The yearly limit is $7,500 for 2026.
There was a bonus I didn’t expect. The dollars you put in, not the growth, can come back out without a penalty. For a nervous saver who had just been burned, that mattered more than I’d like to admit.
None of it felt heroic. It felt like laying boards across a creek, one at a time, until I could walk to the other side.
The part nobody hands you with the enrollment forms
Here’s what I figured out, eventually. The problem was never that I didn’t want to save. The problem was that I’d been handed a destination without a route.
Everyone handed me a destination. Nobody handed me the route.
“Max out your 401(k)” is a destination. The route is a set of steps, and the order does most of the work. Grab the match first, because it’s free. Pay off any debt that charges more than the market can reasonably pay you. Build a cushion so one bad month doesn’t turn into a bad year. Open the Roth IRA. Then, and only then, start climbing back toward that big 401(k) number.
I raised my 401(k) contribution one percentage point every time I got a raise. I never felt it. By the time I’d worked through the steps, I was putting in far more than 4 percent and still sleeping fine.
Ben Franklin warned about the small leak that sinks the great ship. A 22 percent credit card is that leak with a motor on it. You don’t have to choose between the present and the future. You just have to fix the leak before you load the boat.
Last fall, I parked at that same trailhead. Same road, same gravel, new transmission. I set the water on top of my pack where I could reach it, buckled the strap, and started up the hill.
If you want the same order of operations laid out in plain English, the Personal Finance section at Penny Pencil is about a ten-minute read. You’ll leave knowing which dollar to move first.
About the author
I’m Jared Marino, an economist and writer who spends his weekdays with markets and his weekends on trails. I hold a graduate degree in economics from UNC Chapel Hill and teach at Claros Academy. I got the order of my own retirement saving wrong before I got it right, so I write about personal finance, index investing, and the outdoors for people who’d rather skip that detour. Based in upstate New York.
Follow Jared: Follow Jared · Jared Marino’s Blog Roll · Private Equity Lion
General education, not personalized financial advice.








